NYTimes analysis: Forced
arbitration becoming more prevalent.
The New York Times (11/1, A1, Silver-Greenberg,
Gebeloff, Subscription Publication, 11.64M) reports on “a far-reaching power
play orchestrated by American corporations.” By “inserting individual
arbitration clauses into a soaring number of consumer and employment contracts,
companies like American Express devised a way to circumvent the courts and bar
people from joining together in class-action lawsuits, realistically the only
tool citizens have to fight illegal or deceitful business practices.” The Times
notes that “over the last few years, it has become increasingly difficult to
apply for a credit card, use a cellphone, get cable or Internet service, or
shop online without agreeing to private arbitration,” as well as “getting a
job, renting a car or placing a relative in a nursing home.” According to the
Times, “some state judges have called the class-action bans a ‘get out of jail
free’ card, because it is nearly impossible for one individual to take on a
corporation with vast resources.”
Forced
arbitration seen favoring corporations. The New York Times (11/2, A1, Silver-Greenberg,
Corkery, Subscription Publication, 11.64M) reports that Deborah L. Pierce, an emergency
room doctor in Philadelphia, “was optimistic when she brought a sex
discrimination claim against the medical group that had dismissed her,” but
“she began to worry, though, once she was blocked from court and forced into
private arbitration,” where a corporate attorney who also handled arbitrations
ultimately ruled against her. An investigation by the Times found that
arbitration “often bears little resemblance to court,” and that “over the last
10 years, thousands of businesses across the country – from big corporations to
storefront shops – have used arbitration to create an alternate system of
justice.” Under arbitration, “rules tend to favor businesses, and judges and
juries have been replaced by arbitrators who commonly consider the companies their
clients, The Times found.”
No comments:
Post a Comment